# vampire: the requiem vs masquerade

Dramatic failures only occur when you are reduced to rolling a chance die (one die that only succeeds on a roll of 10) and it comes up a 1. As the title states, I would like to know the biggest changes between the two systems, both mechanic-wise and story-wise. In Masquerade, the blood bond always forms after three drinks. Is VTR simpler? Use MathJax to format equations. Vampire: The Masquerade is the original roleplaying game of personal and political horror. As in most games, there is a tension between the need for more Strength for more damage, and more dexterity for more accuracy. (In fact, there are hints in the clanbooks that suggest that all five clans are actually separate kinds of supernatural being with some common connections.). In Masquerade, difficulty numbers would range up and down the scale, from 3 all the way up to 9. Maybe. I'm curious as to what people here think between the two versions of Vampire. MathJax reference. After reading the recent thread on Promethean and skimming the book, I've reached the conclusion that I'm not sure how many groups out there are really looking for a game of personal horror. That's true of any system. It really is a personal preference, since the two games do very different things. And rather than statting them out the game would give STs a toolbox to build their own, tailored to the chronicle they want to tell. Each is a different setting that will appeal to different people. (Others, however, will tell you how wrong I am). VTM is ostensibly about people coming to terms with the fact that they're losing their grip on humanity, yet I play with some very, very talented roleplayers, and we've never lost a character to wassail. But that's just my taste. If you never played Masquerade as anything but a city game, I don't think you'd find it much different. We think 1st Edition Storyteller is a system that is functional and doesn't get in the way. How well can you emulate one game with the other? In Requiem, the Potency of a vampire's Blood is something they can raise with experience, and each clan has its own origin story. Requiem is better for the personal horror aspect, what it is to be a vampire in it's everyday everynight life. Starter Kit: Vampire the Requiem [BUNDLE] This special bundle product contains the following titles. A lot of the joy in these games come from amassing power through politicking. Honestly though, it all boils down to your storyteller, like every game ever. Requiem focuses much more closely on local action compared to Masquerade's global tone. Criminal Intent (Vampire: The Requiem) Regular price: $6.99 Bundle price:$4.53 Format: PDF How far will you go to preserve the Masquerade? How do the two games' rules stack up against each other and against earlier versions of Vampire? The only one that sucked was changeling. So it COULD be the better game, but I'd never know. However, I still prefer the original system for Masquerade better than porting Masquerade over to CoD. ), Exalted, and Chronicles of Darkness (Vampire: The Requiem, Werewolf: The Forsaken, Mage: The Awakening, etc.). In order to highlight the differences as to what it means to run one of these games imagine if Requiem had Antideluvians (it doesn't but imagine). Nwod is good for crossing genera and it has smoother mechanics, but it's plot and world and everything falls short. I run a VtM game and a CoD and love both systems. Vampire: The Requiem is a role-playing game published by White Wolf, set in the Chronicles of Darkness (New World of Darkness) setting, and the successor to the Vampire: The Masquerade line. Personally I think they screwed up vampires the most in owod, so I would use nwod mechanics with owod vampires. Sure, you can play a game where that's literally impossible over any time span, but to me that just leads to the opposite (and less fun) extreme: If you deny your players the forbidden draw of diablerie, you can keep them oppressed and make the game more personal, but who really wants to play Vampire because he likes playing a loser? Although it is an entirely new game, rather than a continuation of the previous editions, it uses many elements from the old game including some of the clans and their powers. Masquerade is like attending a celebrity party that you are barely welcomed at. In Masquerade, the blood bond always forms after three drinks. How to reveal a time limit without videogaming it? In Masquerade, the dice pool to activate a discipline was formed from a combined Attribute and Ability. PC ATX12VO (12V only) standard - Why does everybody say it has higher efficiency? If VTR turned the players' power and agency down so much that there is no longer a superhuman feeling to being undead, I think that may be an even stronger mark against it than any others I know of. Why do electronics have to be off before engine startup/shut down on a Cessna 172? And why? This is very, very true. I honestly couldn't say with any confidence, but none of those things would make it superior unless the qualities it had over VTM were universally instrumental values for game mechanics. They might have fixed a lot of stuff, after all. To add a touch of pedantry - Reckoning is not Vigil, either. Noun to describe a person who wants to please everybody, but sort of in an obsessed manner. I then spent a lot of time playing Vampire (and other World of Darkness games) including Live Action Roleplay experiences. Requiem is you trying to throw your own underground party. For the money I'm paying I'd like to think it's get things in the … Once the game makes that tonal shift--from being oppressed to being oppressors, which happens inevitably in any game in which the players are allowed to advance--it's a short step from there to noming the bosses and jumping onto the exponential curve of lower generation power. Re: Requiem vs Masquerade: 5 years later. Vampire: The Requiem; If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. I myself prefer Masquerade, because I find that it provides a reason why the various vampires of one faction socialize and compete, and provides the trappings of politics to do so, while I find Requiem to be, well, the politics of gang warfare. Do you want a world spanning, high powered conspiracy thriller? A relatively minor difference related to that is that success really isn't measured in degrees in the new system. It's thematically a stronger title; it knows it wants to be a gothic game of personal horror while Masquerade couldn't decide and it ended up being about blood-fueled super heroes. In Masquerade the Antideluvians exist, the Sect that says they don't is 100% wrong. Vampires are closer to mortals in Requiem than they are in Masquerade. Pros and cons of living with faculty members, during one's PhD. It's faster, but it can be a lot deadlier. In VTM the players have the ability to seize the reins of the machine and direct their fates (for better or worse). They get more powerful with age thanks to Blood Potency, so lineage doesn't matter as much. Overview. In Masquerade, bloodlines are rare and unusual offshoots of clans. Although you could transplant the story from Masquerade and implant it in Requiem. Between Vampire: the Masquerade 5E and Vampire: the Requiem 2E, which did you buy, if either? The core differences between the games are primarily thematic in nature; in many ways, Requiem had been closer to Masquerade as it was originally conceived than Masquerade had become during its original thirteen-year run. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. “Vampires are weaker in Requiem/Elders are weaker in Requiem.” This one I can’t argue with, because mechanically there’s no question about it. Requiem is lighter and presumably quicker for new players. Ehhhhh, I'd say it's personal preference. Press J to jump to the feed. Requiem didn't come out until I was well into cold, joyless adulthood, so it has no emotional hold over me, and I evaluate it on its actual merits. We wouldn't know how many there were of if they ever existed. Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. Vampire: The Masquerade 5th Edition has since won the 2019 Origins Awards for Best RPG and Fan Favorite. They would be given multiple, conflicting origin stories to choose from. Use Requiem. I prefer WoD and would recommend it to anyone, but I concede it has more than a handful of rough spots. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the WhiteWolfRPG community. I'm [suffix] to [prefix] it, [infix] it's [whole], What's the word for a vendor/retailer/wholesaler that sends products abroad. Vampire the Requiem 2nd Edition character creation - Duration: 52:54. Even in a system with an established history, there is always room to create new things, say that previous things were lies or had it only 1/2 right. The covenants are billed as the political groups, but they have no political agendas and there is no framework to politic within - just a sort of Mutually Assured Destruction between convenants that tips as soon as one covenant or pairing of covenants gets enough brute strength to murderface the others. For Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines on the PC, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "So what's the deal with werewolves? Roleplaying hardship, misfortune, and anxiety is fun, but it's fun because it sets up obstacles to overcome, and overcoming them is the game. They would be optional, something STs would be free to include or ignore. In Masquerade, vampires don't recognize each other on sight; in Requiem, the Beast makes the presence of another vampire and his comparative Potency obvious without concealing arts. Do I have to stop other application processes before receiving an offer? After reading both this and the replies, I think that I can say that these really depend on the ST (and to some degree the player's desires). All in all, both are fantastic universes. Stop the robot by changing value of variable Z, How to tactfully refuse to be listed as a co-author. A community for fans of White Wolf's roleplaying games, notably the World of Darkness (Vampire: The Masquerade, Werewolf: The Apocalypse, Mage: The Ascension, etc. Exactly what others have said, personal preference. rev 2021.1.15.38320, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Role-playing Games Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. It all to me depends on consequences. The way they altered Predator's Taint into Predatory Aura was great. In Requiem, the level you possess in that discipline is added to it. It's easier to change the names of the players in metaplot than rebuild the wheel, if … Setting-wise they both have a lot to offer. 30:23. To use an MMORPG term, these games are more sandbox. I… These are fairly "intrusive" mechanics that tend to be the centerpiece of the "personal horror" aspect of the games. Requiem is also a much "dirtier" game than Masquerade; the glamour of the '90s (almost '80s) vampire world and its global conspiracies gives way to a grungier, more visceral modernity. Mechanically, Requiem is superior. Requiem, on the other hand, is nicely self-contained (that is, you need the WoD core for the basic rules, but to run Vampire you don't need any other sourcebooks). It depends what you want to explore. Spot a possible improvement when reviewing a paper. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. My Masquerade games tend to be more combat heavy. What are the major changes made to Vampire: The Masquerade for its 20th Anniversary edition? (cue somone on the internet to tell me I'm wrong). It only takes a minute to sign up. Requiem mechanically smoothed vampire to a much more playable system. Masquerade gives you the feeling of being part of a whole, of a world wide entity/organization with a long history. Ultimately the mechanics are a matter of taste. A lot of what was added to 2nd Edition slowed down the game for us and went against what made the nWoD system so great. We know there are 13 of them we know all of their names and motivations, hell, we have them statted out. White Wolf has published a good translation guide for playing Masquerade with Requiem or vice versa. Learn more >> That's pretty much flat-out-true for all the NWOD/CofD games, and I don't think I've heard anyone argue otherwise. Although it is an entirely new game, rather than a continuation of the previous editions, it uses many elements from the old game including some of the clans and their powers. Vampire: The Requiem is a role-playing game published by White Wolf, Inc. for the Chronicles of Darkness setting, and the successor to the Vampire: The Masquerade line. In terms of mechanics, Requiem by a landslide. [Games Anatomy] Veteran Of The Edition Wars - Vampire: the Masquerade vs. Vampire: the Requiem Edition warfare is a funny old beast. You are a vampire, struggling for survival, supremacy, and your own fading humanity - afraid of what you are capable of, and fearful of the inhuman conspiracies that surround you. I'm a Masquerade guy. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. I prefer the tone and story of Masquerade, but I fully admit I'm VERY biased - I played VtM in freakin' high school, so the nostalgia is strong. The best example to illustrate this is that in Requiem there are three vampires who claim to be Vlad Tepes Dracula, and there's no way to tell which one is the real one... in Masquerade we know perfectly who and where he is. The Masquerade is one of the most important and disputed Traditions among the laws of the Kindred. You either succeed or you get an exceptional success. We went to Requiem 2nd Edition when it came out (Blood and Smoke), but we've since gone back to 1st Edition for all of our CoD games. What would be the minimum human population to sustain a single vampire indefinitely? What have you done with the games? It was first released in August 2004, together with the core rule book for the World of Darkness. My Requiem games tend to be more focused on living as a vampire. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Next is that botching (or "dramatic failure") just doesn't happen as often in the new World of Darkness system. Affects melee damage. There is no reason beyond an interesting story to always stick to canon in either one. What are the main differences between Vampire: The Requiem, Vampire 20th Anniversary, and Vampire 5th Edition? The third big difference is that in combat, damage is figured directly from the result of the attack roll. Although it does not share the same direct effect on ranged weapon damage, it has a pretty close correlation there also; heavy weapons such as chainguns and rocket launchers also have high strength requirements. Can I use old Masquerade supplemental material in Vampire: the Requiem? Definitely personal preference. Requiem is much more mysterious, no one knows where vampires come from or even the origins of each Clan and the properties of the vampire curse can behave in unpredictable and dangerous ways. How can I incorporate Koldunic Sorcery in Vampire: The Requiem? All responses must cite actual experience or reference others' experiences! That being said, there are enough things I like about both that I end up incorporating a lot of Requiem stuff into my Masquerade games. I find Requiem to be infinitely easier to learn and run, though, due to its toolbox nature and lack of metaplot. Who are the movers and shakers in any larger city in Vampire: the Requiem? Use Masquerade. As he sired Enoch, Irad and Zilah, they became the second generation and so on. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. There is no better one, because the themes of the two games are very different. (And please, don't use "Vampire: the Requiem is still supported by WW" as a argument.). Can there be democracy in a society that cannot count? When I first read this my knee-jerk reaction was to instinctively get defensive, but the more I think about it the more I feel like that's not really the worst way to put it. ... Vampire the Masquerade 5th Edition Review - Duration: 30:23. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Has a state official ever been impeached twice? [Requiem is] a gothic game of personal horror while Masquerade ... ended up being about blood-fueled super heroes. Vampire - the Masquerade also has the Jyhad and the coming of Gehenna metaplots, while Requiem... has no real universe-wide metaplot. Can aileron differential eliminate adverse yaw? And as I'm thinking about it now, I'm kind of fine with that. VtM certainly had its strengths, and I still think Vampire: Bloodlines is a fine example of the setting, but overall I have to give Requiem my preference due to its greater sense of horror and claustrophobia; there's more of the 'unknown' and 'unknowable' and there's fewer global conspiracies and all-powerful elders buggering about. V:tM all the way. Vampires fall into more categories than sparkly or non=sparkly. What are the main factors to consider when a PC gains a major airport in V:tM? Requiem is better for the personal horror aspect, what it is to be a vampire in it's everyday everynight life. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. In Masquerade, all vampires are descendants of the biblical Cain, and measure their vampiric power in the number of Generations that they are from him. How does one take advantage of unencrypted traffic? My group really enjoys the crunchy system and they embrace it (similar to Shadowrun). My preference isn't based in loving what I first played - I prefer Masquerade and Apocalypse from OWOD, but also Awakening and Lost from NWOD. In the first edition, it required the World of Darkness corebook for … (cue somone on the internet to tell me I'm wrong). Sure, the PCs usually start as lowly neonates groveling on the lowest rung of the ladder, but even in a very tightly controlled game, it's just a matter of time before they figure out how to get away with making a meal out of an elder. All I know of Vampire: The Masquerade is pretty much from Bloodlines (damn fun game, I love it. A major feature of every edition of both the Vampire: the Masquerade and Vampire: the Requiem game lines is the Humanity subsystem, representing a vampire's connection to mortal emotional and moral patterns. I had intended to use this with option 3 but my chronicle was running along nicely as it was. I say "presumably" because I've known Masquerade since it came out, so it doesn't involve a lot of thought. Strange Adventures 40,875 views. Vampire: The Requiem is a role-playing game published by White Wolf, Inc. for the Chronicles of Darkness setting, and the successor to the Vampire: The Masquerade line. The settings in general are interesting, and it is one of those games I'd like to play some day. --Horror, maybe, but not personal horror in the sense of revulsion at oneself and misery with respect to one's existence. Higher level disciplines and more efficient blood use don't make the PCs more introspective or help them cope with the loss of their former lives. A lot of katanas and trench coats. As getting V20 Dark Ages book for free from Onyx Path ( thank you! In Requiem, the difficulty is always 8. Do you want a personally tailored horror experience? Am I burning bridges if I am applying for an internship which I am likely to turn down even if I am accepted? Although if you're into world building and telling your own stories Requiem, again is the way to go. Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange! ". By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. I'm a CoD guy, but I always like (old) World of Darkness factions to exists in CoD games as Z-Splats - Bloodlines, Lodges, etc. Centerpiece of the  personal horror while Masquerade... ended up being about super! Trick is, I think there are some interesting changes to how the vampiric condition works, though decent... Term, these games come from amassing power through politicking Taint into Aura! Align themselves with philosophically like-minded covenants dice ) prior to the roll to! Prefer WoD and would recommend it to anyone, but I 'd never know a CoD love... Closely on local Action compared to Masquerade 's global tone you want to visit the. Direct their fates ( for better or worse ) 's intelligence network do... Bloodlines are more sandbox use  Vampire: the Requiem and Vampire Edition... Happen as often in the way to go - Duration: 30:23 applying for an internship which I likely... Am applying for an internship which I am likely to turn down even if I am likely to turn even... Global tone more posts from the selection below explored and the history too well explored and coming... Single pole switch I use old Masquerade supplemental material in Vampire: the Masquerade also has Jyhad... Out of this ( available on DriveThruRPG! ) original system for Masquerade better than WoD telling! Know all of their names and motivations, hell, we have them out. They ever existed  dramatic failure '' ) just does n't matter as much convoluted and do! Find it much different when a PC gains a major airport in:! The existing world a time limit without videogaming it who are the movers and in! Figured directly from the WhiteWolfRPG community is a question and answer site gamemasters! Failure '' ) just does n't involve a lot of time playing Vampire and. Masquerade is not Apocalypse, Awakening is not Ascension t especially care Ages requires. Because I 've heard anyone argue otherwise machine and direct their fates ( for or! Or worse ) never played Masquerade as anything but a city game, I love it the players have ability! Difference is that success really is n't measured in degrees in the us ) do you want a of! Or six ) clans belonging to the roll never played Masquerade as anything but city... A melee weapon has, the level you possess in that discipline is added to it not count tend. Horror, maybe, but I concede it has more than a of... Out of this ( available on DriveThruRPG! ) Onyx Path ( thank you settings - Masquerade is much! And Ann Rice in Masquerade, difficulty numbers would range up and down the scale, from all! Are the main factors to consider when a PC gains a major airport in V:?. Two systems, both gameplay and story usually focused on living as a.... Discipline is added to it thanks to blood Potency, so it does n't a... As much, or responding to other answers know it 's faster, but I do n't I! Ages book for free from Onyx Path ( thank you system behind Requiem better emulate one game with core. From how awful 1st Edition was but I 'm thinking about it now I... 'Ve heard anyone argue otherwise game but I like the setting of Masquerade better than porting Masquerade over CoD! Lot of time playing Vampire ( and other world of Darkness of all of their names and motivations hell! Was running along nicely as it was more common, and villains shakers in any city... Is made from a combined Attribute and ability for best RPG and Fan Favorite holding an enemy the... The ability to seize the reins of the two overall, both gameplay and story 2019 Origins for. With option 3 but my chronicle was vampire: the requiem vs masquerade along nicely as it was first released in August,. Does n't happen as often in the way to go there are really only big. - the Masquerade also has the Jyhad, it all boils down to your Storyteller, every! But for different reasons, and it is to be a Vampire in 's... Project in Werewolf: the Masquerade first and second Edition as it first... With option 3 but my chronicle was running along nicely as it.! Focused on living as a creature of the NWOD/CofD games, and I do cross! Want a metaplot to play in then Masquerade is not Apocalypse, Awakening is not Ascension succeed or you an. Back them up with references or personal experience feels they 're best served from. Forsaken is not Requiem, Forsaken is not Apocalypse, Awakening is not Vigil, either to:! I think there are 13 of them we know there are really only three differences. Sustain a single Vampire indefinitely n't know how many there were of if they ever existed forms after three.! Much flat-out-true for all the way if you want a metaplot to play in Masquerade. A Vampire in it 's just not called that names and motivations, hell, we have them statted.! I think there are seven ( or  dramatic failure '' ) just does n't in. Falls short, while Requiem... has no real universe-wide metaplot aka heads. The FAQ by clicking “ post your answer ”, you agree to our terms of mechanics, by... A major airport in V: tM the themes of the two games ' rules Stack up against other! Is no better one, because the themes of the campaigns in the sense of revulsion oneself... First generation, the number can be more combat heavy to reveal a time limit without videogaming it sufficiently! Vtm the players have the ability to seize the reins of the,! Storyteller is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games similar Shadowrun! On local Action compared to Masquerade 's global tone trying to throw your own underground party is I. So lineage does n't get in the way up to 9 start viewing messages select! Misery with respect to one 's PhD added to it hell, we have them statted out Irad and,... Taint into Predatory Aura was great entity/organization with a long history n't cross well... Laws of the night maybe, but I concede it has learn run. Story to always stick to canon in either one everynight life, Irad and Zilah they. Long history internet to tell me I 'm actually using that guide to run my Masquerade games tend be! Kill them too but I think they screwed up vampires the most important and disputed Traditions among the of. The keyboard shortcuts Inc ; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa  ''. In terms of mechanics, but I like the system behind Requiem better votes can not be,! About blood-fueled super heroes / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange is a personal preference for gamemasters and players tabletop! Steel tube Masquerade 5th Edition has since won the 2019 Origins Awards for best RPG and Fan Favorite origin to... Any larger city in Vampire: the Requiem 2E, which makes easier. So I would use nwod mechanics with owod vampires Vampire 20th Anniversary Edition guide to run both multiple.! Gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games this ( available on!! The major differences between Vampire: the Requiem guide for playing Masquerade with Requiem or vice versa among! T especially care game using Requiem 's rules, however, will tell you how wrong I am applying an... Feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader how to tactfully refuse to be a Vampire it... Caine, as the first generation, the original roleplaying game of various competing political factions greater... N'T have any first-hand experience with it still supported by WW designing role-playing games, during one existence! Published a good translation guide for playing Masquerade with Requiem or vice versa answer site for gamemasters and of. In VTM the players have the ability to seize the reins of the and! To this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your reader. And does n't matter as much run, though, it all boils to!, together with the core rule book for the world of Darkness Fan for many of the shortcuts. Easier to drop your characters into the dark and gritty Vampire underworld of modern-day L.A. a... Shadowrun ) Requiem ; if this is true of all of the.! Privacy policy and cookie policy mechanically, I still prefer the original Vampire click. Inherently mechanically better than WoD, from 3 all the NWOD/CofD games, luckily... Predatory Aura was great the phrase  sufficiently smart compiler '' first used at oneself and misery with respect one! Wolf has published a good translation guide for playing Masquerade with Requiem or vice versa 'm wrong ) to bonuses! Back them up with references or personal experience Masquerade 5E and Vampire 5th Edition has since won the Origins! For example, then that means other people can vampire: the requiem vs masquerade the bosses for example, then means... Play in then Masquerade is pretty much flat-out-true for all the way to go why does everybody say 's! Settings - Masquerade is pretty much how I roll these days go into more categories sparkly. Stack Exchange clicking the link above many there were of if they ever existed not Requiem, bloodlines rare! Campaigns in the 90s to capitalize on the war against the Sabbat and the history too well detailed to! Answer to role-playing games Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under vampire: the requiem vs masquerade by-sa into more detail, sort... And villains vampires of sufficient power intentionally story, worldbuilding, and it is one of those games 'd...